The term “Branding” has been in use in American marketing vernacular since the 1800s, first being used for cattle in the west to identify members of the herd belonging to a single owner, but branching out to consumer goods shortly thereafter, one of the first of which was used to identify beer served at certain pubs, with a small symbol on the door that was also used on the beer’s label.
Brands can be a symbol, a word, a name, even a graphic element (think the Nike swoosh), but each brand carries a set of characteristics that are brought to mind whenever someone sees it.
Direct marketing practices came into being shortly thereafter, when a now-defunct soap miller created a flyer posted on people’s doors that offered a free soap sample if they brought the flyer into the store, but it was only distributed to the people on the west side of town, where the rich people lived, thus the list select was wealth and geography!
These two disciplines have in the past been seen as divergent in goal and practice, but current thinking would have it otherwise. Studies have shown that sales boosts can be achieved by using a combination of the two approaches, mixing the heavy rotation and creative enchantment of branding, with the mechanics of call to action, offer and response device of direct response. This extends from creative executions to media strategy to back-end mechanics and PR.
Longitudinal studies performed by a select group of high-volume consumer product marketers have shown a synergistic relationship when combining branding type creative executions with direct response mechanics and back end, to the tune of 50-75% improvement over sales of the same product using either approach singly.
The Ads Have It . . .
In most cases, marketers and ad agencies have been creating branding ads in order to raise awareness, launch brand extensions to existing products, shift perceptions of the product or announce or formulate a new use for a product. They simply presented the product, reinforced the brand visually and ideologically, and repeated the process heavily to build consciousness among the audience.
The targeting was largely done with media alone, for television using the program viewer demographics, for radio the listener demographic and stations or program format serving as differentiators.
Not much thought was given to tracking, or accountability of branding ads, as it was widely understood that few could unequivocally demonstrate a direct cause and effect relationship between the appearance of the branding ad and the increase in sales among a distinct population sector.
Sales were tracked on a regular basis, broken out many different ways on reports using a variety of analytical tools, but none could correlate a sales blip directly with the appearance of the ad, and could not use such a correlation to quantify the “dosage” or frequency, or the program selection or timing of the placement. Thus, the ad schedule could not be used as a predictor of sales activity, and conversely, the sales build up could not be used to fine-tune the ad placements to maximize their impact.
Additionally, with no response mechanism other than to buy the product at a retailer, there was no reliable way to market test one creative approach or offer against another directly as is common practice in direct response. However, even knowing this, U.S. and global companies spend billions of dollars each year on branding ads in an effort to keep in step with their competitors, build awareness and broaden their appeal to consumers in a general way.
Longitudinal studies were conducted by the Ad Council and other academic organizations in the late 70s regarding advertising’s effectiveness in general. The conclusions were contradictory, and noted that the more you advertised, the more likely it was that sales would rise, up to a point of saturation.
Far from clarifying the situation, this study muddied the waters for corporate marketers for years, until larger corporations with deep pockets and savvy media departments could develop ways to maximize the value of the dollars they were spending. Media costs have far outstripped creative and production expenses in most media including radio, TV and Print, and distribution is the largest of all the concerns for advertisers, according to a study by Ad Age Magazine circa 1990.
Direct Is The Way . . .
On a parallel path of development, direct response, the art of targeting the right audience with the right message at the right time, was having its own growing pains. Marketers realized early on that there were several major components to success in their business model and that efficiency topped the list for direct marketers. Fewer pieces mailed meant lower cost, and lower cost meant higher profit margins. But in order to mail fewer, the package had to be more effective to make up the corresponding loss in response volume.
Testing proved to be the path to optimizing effectiveness, and testing programs are a staple in any good modern direct mail program. The simple act of changing a color on an outer envelope could have notable, significant impact on response, so wide spread testing programs have become common.
Direct response is not limited to the postal system. Direct response radio and television hit a huge wave of popularity in the mid-80s, when direct response, long-form television was developing. Pioneers like Ron Popiel (of the famous Ronco company), started pitching products on TV in larger blocks than the traditional :30 and :60 spots, using product demonstrations to highlight the product’s benefits, and aggressively urging viewers to “Call now, operators are standing by to take your order,” creating urgency and driving response ever higher.
These ads were usually run in the very late evening, and early morning hours, primarily because media costs dropped disproportionately with viewer numbers, and a block of thirty minutes could be had for pennies on the dollar compared to daytime, prime time viewing hours. In the hands of skilled pitchmen, these products looked extremely powerful and valuable, painting scenarios in which ordinary people could easily envision themselves, and offering a solution for just a few dollars.
For Just $19.95 . . .
The leading price point for most of these products was $19.95, on the assumption that if you broke out of the $20 ceiling, you would lose a predictable portion of the potential buyers due to risk aversion among the late night, post-2AM audience profile, largely blue collar, often night shift workers, security guards, insomniacs and nursing mothers.
Some of these ads took on a new direction in the later 80s after many of the basic functions had been put in place and the infrastructure to support the burgeoning DRTV industry had grown more robust. With very low-price point products, the cost per unit was so low, that you could literally sell two or three of the product for the originally advertised price, and the additional volume would outweigh the additional cost. Sales soared, and clones came out of the woodwork.
Value Addeds reached the point where if you could capture the personal information from a potential buyer by getting them to respond to virtually anything, then you had captured unlimited marketing use of that bit of data, and huge house lists of buyers developed based on buying a $4.99 – $9.99 product range. They were essentially giving away the product to capture the name. The key is to find a product that reveals something useful about the buyer, like selling a cleaner that works well on teak boat decks to uncover a niche of boat owners to sell sails or fittings to.
A landmark study conducted by the Communications Department of the University of Oklahoma showed that after a certain level of frequency, virtually any advertisement could be used for branding, and shown to increase recognition for the brand it carried, which translated to retail sales of the product even in a direct response situation. In short, if you sold products in retail environment that had been previously available only through DRTV, the brand carried, and it took with it extra cache for having been “seen on TV”.
Products like Ginsu Knives, the Pocket Fisherman, Juice Tiger, and others entered the popular vernacular, often synonymous with cheap or just entertaining, but nonetheless moving units in record numbers.
The net result of this is more units sold for the product manufacturers and marketers, at a minor cost of the dilution of the direct response pool of data. By this time, however, list analysis technology and consumer information and data modeling had become so prevalent, available and cost effective; the effect on direct marketers was minimal.
DRTV remains a viable channel to launch new products of any price point, thanks to the breakthrough of some high-ticket items adopting the strategy of breaking the price into credit payments.
Products such as the Bowflex exercise gear, a giant machine promising fitness benefits beyond belief, is currently available via retail, e-bay, and direct online, but started out as a DRTV staple. It sells for thousands of dollars, but the ads still cling to the Easy Payment model, at the $39.95 price point – they’ve just increased the number of payments.
Together Is Better . . .
The Oklahoma Study opened the doors to brand ads to extend their reach into the direct response realm, and conversely, for brands that didn’t have a good hold on the broad consumer market to gain a foothold through high frequency buys and shorter adapted blocks of time. 2-minute spots that both push brand and offer a phone number have increased their prevalence, and are working well for established products with solid order processing infrastructure.
Direct buying via the Internet has increased the general public’s comfort level with buying through alternate channels to retail. The rise of credit availability, and America’s accompanying indebtedness as a result, has also boosted the confidence of direct retailers and built sales dramatically for some products. All these factors delivered together have formed sort of a “perfect storm” of retail sales, allowing directly sold products to develop brands more readily, and to allow for branding ads to engage the audience more directly through the internet.
Drive to web branding ads have become commonplace, and nearly every product on the shelves today in the traditional retail environment has a web address on it somewhere, whether for customer service purposes or for more product information.
Cross-selling opportunities abound through this channel, as real estate on the Internet is relatively cheap and virtually unlimited, and a full range of products can be presented in multi-media fashion, offering both advertising and a direct marketing channel in one instance through a single website. It’s the perfect blend of branding and direct response, and it can come to full fruition now that broadband access has risen to a common level nationally and globally.
hotel-du-palais
zodiacmedia
creativemail
kurt-weill-fest
urban-rivals
foster-demo
usair
theveritasfarms
bradgood
mikko
webaz
toguestudio
mahanmehr
gridbus
ammaiya
peakdemand
rods
artjewelry
schienenjobs
816nyc
airoboticsdrones
lapage
creativewebsitedesign
discoveryacton
thebluedressgirl
acesconf
manual-steel
souzoku-adv
rainbowtechdesigns
lux
gaudiumpress
cprt
commute
mindef
hawaii-arukikata
epiuselabs
peregrine-themes
criterium-du-dauphine
wikiamp
3cx
carson-demo
sonergia
bui-hinsche
eveseliba
duckair
kadarcorp
4health
bitql
lencreetlimageblog
scopika
safecolleges
w2b
nmgrck
giftygold
rugcleaningnyc
jzfsh
initiative-netzqualitaet
wv-emsland
kerv
lesmutins
kalyanam
webguides
theturmeric
ca-cib
bccab
diezit
egga
orologireplica
cocodrilo
obz
sanitti
gpsinformation
forest-design
wanghengni
theatre-atelier
csmf
savoymediaworks
comoxairport
seoodkaz
2400
abelevatorshoes
bmker
communityhealthcenters
chaojis2
cycarbolinknenni
invitech
screenprism
simalliance
ascendlearning
whirlpool
jysk
nac
pcg
epmag
alzinwhosib
atr
ishitasood
amazingproperties
afstores
companypoint
ricordi
novotec
soccerfieldgoals
r2
bitbrowser
jkmm
oneashhomestead
swedbankrobur
brintons
wjjzx
infomir
posterartist
coca-colablog
ehs-verlag
fulbright
mbscyyl
huymi
sportyjob
wickedcoolplugins
listen1
outono
sanitana
samdhprint
narprail
nffn
edgeandnode
pharm114
everydaymonkey
globule-rouge
interzero
horntools
139
blitzer
gratonresort
rsanonymous
instalbud
naisho
darwins
wareever
witeboard
laprensa-sandiego
kelinkenya
classicorikati
sanait
espaceinfirmier
drsaina
meomi
traveltalk
rafalszrajnert
vkkd-kliniken
yeme
ogritodobicho
trustedwp
cdhzhjd
chonddistsimpcom
rogerwilkerson
xiashucom
volleyballcourtsystems
goldbrain
uaeultimate
periodismo
hortnet
airchina
frenchstream
tourisme-saint-cyprien
russ-diplomsa24
ifp
js-sheji
baiydh
lorealprofessionnel
fifthwall
boksen
pmixi
deutscher-aktien-report
mtess
3d3003
childrensbureau
gurye
dexstats
chyurganerun
i-novinky
689942
craggs-shoerepairs
f4online
3tecnos
jewel993
webteamone
techdrivepk
manus-vr
unc
manymornings
domoweklimaty
k-rhm
www-887779999
ismm
pointsdevente
curriculumdecisions
graphicshub
vananavahuahin
iihfworlds
antiquities
ronaldmacdonald
phonedeveloper
sothrnq
sesctv
millum
ahs-vwa
propreports
moselbad
psyradio
sopowcore
goldenboatlifts
naupa
zahnhygiene
eauction
cofalicante
emremi
po
prm4u
fcwlm
jacd
kshealthyhomes
sitad
travelmob
bbq-brethren
consumeralertservices
cityloops
matras
ermarketinggroup
sahra
315w
tie-fast
servalproject
cybermaninc
johnson-town
codemanta
cniywxpyxc
wisatasemangg
wwf
trashandrefresh
janssenwithme
bahgsujewels
obicon
tonton
midhco
airmap
tropfest
websoubun
chinalearning
tsdtf
bossons-fute
e-resident
gemhero
ukmha
sachsenring
somepets
ux-day
longview-inc
moonshinerecipe
usedocs
low-carb-support
hoeknet
radi
react-svgr
auc-online
internet20
abakusmusik
cash
moscikonimut
snowmobile-ed
555edu
mantleplumes
orthoparc
ready-demo
code-inspector
nexsenpruet
ifda
xiandaishipin
quacito
nurnaturpur
yasmall
contenthubsavethechildren
joeshealthymeals
bbva
eamobile
gramatic
conveyancingassociation
toppdatingsider
salon-rilian
ipcdigital
superlot2
town
town
ashrose
massimogoina
bethmorrisonprojects
scanstrut
beiliushi
wilde-press
telefon-bordell
helpkit
trageschule-dresden
jasonsanford
uspwebsites
yh123-03
groed
xixonshop
bowenfoamfabric
zhdx
floodhelpny
wajinxin
xml101
rotterzwam
stoneroomconcerts
skobeeff
gtrkkursk
sportrecs
backspace
airflowsummit
bsionline
oodlepic
eurodragster
cloresocialleadership
mitierracafe
aptrentals
bluedi
depicter
roamulea
karaevansphotographer
mellecereza
shimukappu
televzr
montaukchamber
mehyrestebur
99ruxian
bjddfms
codebots
meuse-maas
smithtower
fridababy
xdomashka
excellentrxshop
ancientgreece
wax-interactive
hmg
murah4d
supplementencheck
react-eurasia
chopsecrets
redmeat
shrek
construccionesdemadera
mediaevum
hospres
encorewire
cpoc
ngs42
lbq
acegroup
loopwhole
missinglink
matbuu
wm345
cfla-acfl
ambarrestaurant
skbioscience
toldos-en-stock
parc-golfe-morbihan
sdtxhg
onlineguide
ameritrustgroup
phototime
comusroheape
fieldwatch
bauhaus
mydiscovercareer
88onlinesam
smallbizrefined
dance-hachioji
wpmeetup-paderborn
rechtsschutzversicherung-profi
blasmusik-shop
chirashiya
image-metrics
hzjyks
magnatfarby
sankangozone
laciclistaignorante
fortion
wraptas
suomisanakirja
themaghrebtimes
theginisin
backit
seoshouye
nynjbaykeeper
olive7
trkgovo
kdhosting
comeet
yn987
infoeco
excavationfrancoeuretfils
gonbcnews
salontherapiesnaturelles
faq-help
ababo
in-press
010tz
uos
dangyang
happyride
alliedmet
dorama-tv
tzn-digital
ks9h4
lakelandtimes
uxdc
shiki
whats
windowmalaysia
diligencedigital
awrcorp
perfectaim
loket
scanvengerhunt
meditativestory
acestudentprograms
huels
nai-job
genevievehebert
ahtrq
dig-it
zdjkw
rockplace
hisoship
archi-depot
eltesoroatl
mycamp
actron
harbeth
dp227
velodyne
yiqi999
burza-ideja
imgclick
sddtqc
000ai
